Imagine a scenario of modern city states. You live in
Milan but the tax burden has increased and ID cards have been introduced, however the relatively more liberal Turin is under two
hours drive away. You need not learn a new language, nor practically sever your
ties with friends and family to live under a lighter yoke. In such a situation
many would move to Turin putting strain on Milanese finances , effecting genuine
pressure for a less onerous overlord. The smaller the state, the more similar it is
to an actual business - if I don't like Byron Burger and frequent Hub Box
instead, the former could eventually fold so they have to respond to consumer
demand to stay afloat. Contrast this with voting within a large state - even if
you voted for the winning party, which most people don't, there's no real
pressure on them to follow their manifesto commitments as the money keeps
rolling in: it's like signing a five year catering agreement with Heston
Blumenthal to provide rib-eye steak every day and then for Heston to
subcontract the deal to the Animal Liberation Front who will only make vegan
sausages. All I can do in five years time is to vote for Gordon Ramsey and
hope.
Now you may be thinking where does the UKIP fit in here?
It's simple: the European Union. Under the European Communities Act 1973
European Law supersedes UK law: it has effectively declared itself sovereign
over all the member states - it is an embryonic transnational state. The EU has
a flag, an anthem, a president, a parliament and again wants an army. The
project has always been primarily political, rather than economic - note the
Treaty of Rome 1958, the founding treaty, goal of "ever closer
union". The logic of the EU is a federal Europe: effectively a United
States of Europe (USE). In such a situation you couldn't just jump on dingy to
Dublin to escape the talons of Westminster, you'd need a plane to
Paraguay. As such, the USE would likely
be as liberal as Uncle Joe's USSR. Therefore the primary present political goal
is to leave the EU.
The only party with a chance of putting on pressure for a
fair EU referendum is UKIP. Cameron is frankly a liar: when he was vying for
the Tory leadership he gave a cast iron pledge to party members that as Prime
Minster he would have a referendum on the Lisbon treaty; even before he became
PM he reneged on his promise. All Tory PMs since 1970 have been radically
pro-EU with the exception of the later Thatcher Prime Ministership at which
point she was promptly stabbed in the back. If the Tories have an outright
majority without any deal with UKIP, either the EU referendum won't happen or
it will be so skewed as to make Saddam Hussein's Iraq elections look free and
fair.
Now you may fear, and rightly, Red Ed's Labour Party and
so wish to vote for the Tories as a lesser of two evils. However, the practical
difference in the policies of both parties in government between 1979 and today
is negligible. Vote for Red, Blue or Yellow and the ruling class wins. For
instance, whoever is Home Secretary will continue to arrogate more power to the
state in the name of national security: be it the Charles Clarke's Civil Contingencies Bill (aka Blair's
Enabling Act) or Theresa May's Snoopers'
Charter.
In the case of a Labour/ SNP coalition this does offer
something genuinely different: a return to old school socialism. It would be a
bleak time indeed, however it would foster such anti-Scottish sentiments that
there could well be a referendum on England leaving Scotland! Not only would
this reduce the jurisdiction of the state but also mortally wound the Labour
Party.
Finally, if you want a genuinely less burdensome state in
the long run your only option on May 7th is to vote UKIP. If you disagree on
immigration, the NHS and defence it doesn't matter. The only structural limit
on the power of the state is its geographical size - the SNP want to turn the
area north of Hadrian's Wall into the People's Republic of Scotland; after a
number of years so many would try to leave they'd either have to take
inspiration from Berlin's Wall or become a half decent place to live, otherwise
it would make Greece look like El Dorado.
No comments:
Post a Comment